Francis Schaeffer famously urged Christians to do the Lord’s work in the Lord’s way. The principle becomes especially important when the stakes are high, the opposition is real, and we believe we are fighting for something worth protecting. Church leaders rarely struggle to identify the things worth fighting for. We want to defend biblical truth, protect the vulnerable, preserve the church’s faithfulness, confront injustice, and pass the faith to the next generation. These are good and necessary ambitions. But can we fight for the right things in the wrong way? Can we become so committed to defeating evil that we begin to resemble it?
The story of Saul’s first major military victory in 1 Samuel 11 offers a sobering answer. Saul succeeds in delivering Israel from a genuine enemy. Yet the biblical narrator gives us reason to wonder whether the new king’s methods reveal a deeper problem. Saul defeats the serpent, but he has not yet defeated the serpent in himself. For pastors and church leaders, this is more than an interesting detail in an Old Testament narrative. It is a warning about the relationship between power, character, and the mission of God.
The Right Mission Is Not Enough
In 1 Samuel 11, Nahash, the Ammonite king, threatens the Israelite city of Jabesh-gilead. He offers the inhabitants a humiliating condition for surrender: he will gouge out the right eye of every man and bring disgrace upon Israel. The situation is desperate. Israel needs a deliverer. When Saul hears the news, the Spirit of God rushes upon him, and he responds with righteous anger. He rallies the Israelites, leads them into battle, and decisively defeats the Ammonites. The people are delivered, and Saul’s kingship is publicly affirmed. On the surface, this is a success story. The right enemy has been confronted, the right people have been protected, and the right outcome has been achieved. But look more closely at how Saul gathers his army.
He sends pieces of butchered oxen throughout Israel and threatens that the same thing will happen to the oxen of anyone who refuses to follow him and Samuel. The tactic works. The text tells us that the dread of the Lord falls upon the people, and they come out together. Saul wins the battle, but he mobilizes Israel through intimidation. The man who will deliver his people from a cruel oppressor threatens his own people with violence to secure their cooperation. The parallel is striking. Nahash threatens bodily mutilation. Saul responds with a different kind of violence. Nahash uses fear to force submission. Saul uses fear to force participation. The enemy is cruel, but the deliverer’s methods begin to resemble those of the enemy.
The irony deepens when we consider the name Nahash, which means “serpent” in Hebrew. The biblical story invites us to hear echoes of Genesis 3. There, the serpent enters the garden and tempts humanity with the promise of power and opened eyes. Here, a serpent threatens to blind God’s people, and Israel’s new king rises to defend them. Will this king be the faithful representative God’s people need? Will he confront the serpent without adopting the serpent’s ways? Saul delivers Israel from its external enemy, but his methods expose a problem within himself. Saul defeats the serpent without first defeating the serpent in himself. That is the danger for every Christian leader. We can be right about the threat, right about the truth, and right about the desired outcome while becoming deeply wrong in how we pursue it.
Power Reveals What Is in Us
The narrator makes an important point about Saul’s success: the Spirit of God empowered him for the task. Saul did not simply summon his own courage or discover some previously hidden leadership ability. God equipped him to accomplish a work that needed to be done. Yet Saul’s empowerment does not mean that his character has been fully transformed. We should be careful not to equate the Spirit’s empowering work in Saul with the permanent indwelling of the Spirit that belongs to the new covenant. Nevertheless, the narrative presents a sobering truth: divine empowerment for a task does not make a leader immune to the distortions of the human heart. Saul has what he needs to win the battle. But the way he wins raises questions about the kind of king he is becoming.
This is a lesson church leaders need to recover. We tend to evaluate leadership by its visible results. Did the initiative succeed? Did the church grow? Was the theological error corrected? Were the people mobilized? Did we protect the congregation from harm? These questions matter. Faithfulness does not mean indifference to results. But results cannot be the only measure of faithfulness. The deeper question is what our pursuit of those results is doing to us.
Power reveals. Give someone authority over a staff, a congregation, a ministry budget, or a denominational institution, and eventually that authority will expose what lies beneath the surface. Under pressure, our insecurities, fears, ambitions, and unexamined habits often emerge. We may begin with a sincere desire to protect the church, only to discover that we have become controlling. We may want to defend truth, only to find ourselves exaggerating, misrepresenting, or humiliating those who disagree with us. We may seek to correct an unhealthy culture, only to create a culture in which people are afraid to speak honestly. The temptation is not always to abandon our convictions. Sometimes it is to pursue our convictions in ways that contradict them. We can fight pride and become proud. We can oppose manipulation and become manipulative. We can defend the church and become un-Christlike. We can pursue justice and become self-righteous. We can insist on biblical faithfulness while treating people made in God’s image as obstacles to overcome rather than neighbors to love. The question is not simply, “Are we fighting for the right thing?” It is also, “What is the fight making us become?”
The Danger of Borrowing the World’s Weapons
Church leaders face real threats. Congregations need protection from false teaching, abusive leadership, destructive behavior, and the many pressures that can undermine Christian faithfulness. Sometimes leaders must make difficult decisions, exercise discipline, confront sin, and draw firm boundaries. Doing the Lord’s work in the Lord’s way does not mean avoiding conflict, weakening conviction, or refusing to exercise authority. Jesus himself confronted hypocrisy, exposed deception, and spoke hard truths. Faithful shepherds cannot simply retreat whenever obedience becomes costly. The issue is not whether we exercise authority, but how we exercise it. The issue is not whether we confront evil, but whether our methods reflect the character of the King we serve.
Consider how easily fear can become a leadership strategy. A pastor who wants to protect a congregation from theological error might cultivate suspicion toward anyone who asks difficult questions. A ministry leader who wants to preserve unity might equate disagreement with disloyalty. A church seeking to defend biblical convictions might use shame, caricature, or public humiliation to silence its opponents. These approaches can produce outward conformity. They may even produce short-term results. But they also train people to fear their leaders rather than trust Christ, to hide their questions rather than seek wisdom, and to equate faithfulness with unquestioning agreement.
The same temptation appears in our public witness. When Christians feel threatened by cultural changes, political opponents, or secular hostility, we can begin to imitate the very habits we deplore. We respond to contempt with contempt, distortion with distortion, and hostility with hostility. We become convinced that the stakes are so high that ordinary Christian virtues can no longer be afforded. But if our defense of truth requires dishonesty, we have compromised the truth we claim to defend. If our pursuit of justice requires contempt for our neighbors, we have lost sight of the people for whom justice matters. If our defense of the church makes us domineering, we have forgotten whose church it is. The church does not need leaders who are less courageous. It needs leaders whose courage is governed by love, whose authority is shaped by humility, and whose zeal is disciplined by the character of Jesus.
We Need a Better King
The story of Saul ultimately points beyond Saul. Israel needs a king who can defeat the serpent without becoming like the serpent. Saul is not that king. David will follow, but he too will reveal the limitations and sins of even Israel’s greatest human king. The biblical story continues until we meet Jesus, the true King. In the wilderness, Jesus faces the tempter and refuses the shortcuts to power and glory offered to him. He will not accomplish his mission through disobedience, manipulation, or self-serving displays of power. He remains faithful to his Father even when faithfulness leads toward suffering. And at the cross, Jesus defeats his enemies in a way Saul could never have imagined. He does not conquer through intimidation or threaten destruction to secure allegiance. He gives himself for his people. The King who could summon heavenly armies instead absorbs violence, bears condemnation, and lays down his life for those he came to save. The promised offspring of the woman crushes the serpent, but he does so through his own wounds. This is not weakness. It is the power of God revealed through sacrificial love.
Jesus does not merely provide an example of better leadership. He does what Saul, David, and every other human leader cannot do: he delivers us from sin and reconciles us to God. Our hope is not that we will become sufficiently virtuous to lead without failure. Our hope is that the crucified and risen King forgives us, transforms us, and continues to sanctify his people by his Spirit. That gospel is essential to faithful leadership. Without it, we will either excuse our failures or despair over them. We will protect our reputations, defend our methods, and justify our harshness because we believe the mission depends on us. But the mission does not depend on us. It belongs to Jesus Christ.
Because he has secured our future, we can admit when our methods have been wrong. Because he has borne our condemnation, we can receive correction without treating it as a threat to our identity. Because he has loved us when we were his enemies, we can pursue the good of people who oppose us. And because he is building his church, we can refuse to manipulate people into producing outcomes that only God can ultimately give. The gospel gives us both the courage to act and the freedom to repent.
Three Questions for Leaders Who Want to Be Faithful
How, then, might we apply the lesson of 1 Samuel 11 to our churches and ministries?
First, examine our methods as carefully as our goals. When an important ministry initiative is at stake, we should ask more than whether it is biblically sound or strategically wise. Are we telling the truth? Are we listening carefully? Are we honoring the dignity of those with whom we disagree? Are we exercising authority in a way that reflects Christ’s strength and gentleness? A good goal does not sanctify every means of achieving it. We must evaluate both.
Second, cultivate character alongside competence. We rightly value theological knowledge, strategic thinking, organizational ability, and effective communication. Churches need capable leaders. But competence without Christlike character can make a leader more dangerous, not less. A gifted leader with an unexamined heart can do considerable damage while appearing successful. Our training, accountability, and patterns of leadership development must therefore address not only what leaders can accomplish but also who they are becoming. We need cultures in which repentance is normal, correction is welcomed, humility is practiced, and integrity matters more than image. This begins with pastors and elders willing to examine themselves before God. We cannot cultivate a culture of repentance in our congregations if we are unwilling to repent ourselves.
Third, measure faithfulness by the character of Christ, not simply by the effectiveness of our strategies. The church is called to proclaim the truth, make disciples, pursue justice, serve our neighbors, and bear witness to the kingdom of God. We should work diligently and wisely toward those ends. But we must never forget that the character of our witness is itself part of our witness. People should encounter in our churches not only the truth of Christ’s teaching but something of the beauty of Christ’s character. Our communities should be places where conviction and compassion belong together, where authority serves rather than dominates, and where the pursuit of holiness is accompanied by patience and grace. This does not guarantee that everyone will approve of us or that every conflict will be resolved peacefully. Faithfulness can be costly. Sometimes the most Christlike response will be unpopular, misunderstood, or opposed. But we must not confuse opposition with failure or visible success with God’s approval. The question is whether our life together increasingly reflects the King we proclaim.
Doing the Lord’s Work in the Lord’s Way
The church in every generation faces the temptation to believe that the urgency of its mission justifies methods it would otherwise reject. We can become so focused on defending the faith that we forget to display the character of the One in whom we believe. 1 Samuel 11 reminds us that even a genuine victory can conceal a deeper defeat. Saul delivers Israel, but the means he employs reveal that the deliverer himself needs deliverance. He can defeat an enemy on the battlefield without yet overcoming the disorder within his own heart.
We should hear this as a warning, but also as an invitation. We do not have to choose between theological conviction and gracious engagement, between courageous leadership and humility, or between faithful doctrine and genuine love. In Jesus Christ, these are not competing goods. They belong together. So let us continue to defend the truth, confront injustice, protect the vulnerable, disciple our congregations, and pursue the renewal of Christ’s church. Let us do so with courage, creativity, wisdom, and perseverance.
But let us also keep asking the harder question: What is our pursuit of these good things making us become? May the Lord deliver us from the temptation to use the world’s weapons in the service of his kingdom. May he give us leaders whose authority reflects the gentleness of Christ, whose convictions are accompanied by humility, and whose strength is expressed through sacrificial love. And may our churches demonstrate, in both what we believe and how we live, that the way of Jesus is not merely the message we proclaim. It is the way we are called to walk. The Lord’s work must be done in the Lord’s way, because the way we pursue the mission is part of the witness we bear to the King.
